Wishing our friends, near and far, continued health, comfort and safety.

Back To Blog

5 Biggest Property Sales on Martha's Vineyard in 2015

It was quite a year for Martha's Vineyard real estate... 2015 brought not only big year-end numbers, but some big sales as well. Just as we did last year, we put together a list of the five most expensive sales of the year. Keep reading to check out the hefty price tags that go along with these incredible homes!

1. Oyster Pond Estate

Oyster Pond Estate in Martha's Vineyard

Address: 58 Oyster Watcha Road, Edgartown

Sale Price: $24,750,000

Despite the fact that this 10.5 acre waterfront property on Oyster Pond never actually hit the open market, it still claims the top spot as not only the most expensive sale of 2015, but the second priciest sale on Martha's Vineyard ever. Not surprising, considering that this luxe, Mark Hutker designed Edgartown home has all you could ever possibly want or need...

2. Katama Bay

Katama Bay Martha's Vineyard

Address: 48 Witchwood Lane, Edgartown

Sale Price: $22,000,000

The second spot in the top five priciest home sales goes to this stunning, 3-acre waterfront estate on the shore of Katama Bay. Some of the highlights of this 21,000 square-foot, Patrick Ahearn designed estate include a deep water dock, bowling alley, and a 2,800 square-foot guest house.

3. Crackatuxet Cove

Crackatuxet Cove Martha's Vineyard

Address: 34 Crackatuxet Cove Road, Edgartown

Sale Price: $21,000,000

Coming in close behind at #3 is a palatial pondfront home on the South Shore in Katama. With water views across the pond to the barrier beach and all the amenities you could possibly desire, it's not hard to believe that this one made the list!

4. Herring Creek

Herring Creek Martha's Vineyard

Address: 27 Butlers Cove, Edgartown

Sale Price: $14,450,000

This Patrick Ahearn designed home is located in Herring Creek Farm on the shore of Butlers Cove Road in Katama. Set on 6 acres, this sprawling farmhouse-style estate includes some amazing water views and private beach access.

5. Edgartown Harbor

Edgartown Harbor Martha's Vineyard

Address: 31 Tower Hill Road, Edgartown

Sale Price: $12,000,000

Rounding out the top five list is "Chapeda Hill" - a waterfront home perched high on a bluff overlooking the harbor and beyond. It includes a one-of-a-kind sandy beach, deep water dock and two unique outbuildings - the "Playhouse" and the "Boathouse."

.    .    .

Interested in checking out more island properties?

Click here to search all Martha's Vineyard real estate listings

Add Comment

Comments are moderated. Please be patient if your comment does not appear immediately. Thank you.


  1. No comments. Be the first to comment.

View Our

Recommended Searches

View Categories