The Ultimate Guide to Cocktails, Beer, and Nightlife on the Island
Introduction
When most people think of Martha’s Vineyard, they imagine stunning beaches, charming towns, and a laid-back vibe. However, the Island is also a fantastic destination for anyone looking to enjoy a good drink. Whether you’re in search of handcrafted cocktails, locally brewed beer, or a cozy wine bar, Martha’s Vineyard offers a diverse selection of spots for every taste.
From vibrant nightlife in Oak Bluffs to sophisticated lounges in Edgartown, here’s your complete guide to where to grab the best drinks on Martha’s Vineyard.
Drinks in Edgartown
1. Town Bar & Grill
Located just minutes from downtown, Town Bar & Grill is a lively spot with something for everyone. The menu features creative comfort food, fresh sushi, and an impressive array of seasonal craft cocktails and draft beers. Its laid-back yet upscale vibe makes it a must-visit.
2. Alchemy Bistro & Bar
For an elevated cocktail experience, head to Alchemy in downtown Edgartown. This charming restaurant has consistently been awarded “Best Cocktails on Martha’s Vineyard” and offers a curated wine list alongside its craft drink menu.
3. Bad Martha Farmer’s Brewery
Just outside the bustling downtown area, Bad Martha Farmer’s Brewery serves fresh, Island-inspired beers like Martha’s Vineyard Ale and Long Point Sumac Pilsner. Enjoy a flight in their outdoor beer garden or take a growler to go.
4. The Pelican Club
The Pelican Club, located at 23 Kelly Street in Edgartown within Faraway Martha's Vineyard, offers a sophisticated yet laid-back dining experience. Known for its fresh sushi creations, such as the Edgartown Roll and crispy rice spicy tuna, the menu also features inventive ceviches and sashimi, perfectly paired with exotic cocktails crafted from unique ingredients like mezcal and refreshing slushies. With its open-air setting and relaxed atmosphere under stylish umbrellas, The Pelican Club is the ideal spot for enjoying leisurely meals with friends. While primarily a seasonal destination, it has also hosted special events like Christmas in Edgartown, adding a touch of festive charm to its repertoire.
Insider Tip: Stop by Our Market or Jim’s Package Store in Oak Bluffs to stock up on your favorite drinks for your vacation rental.
Pro Tip: Don’t miss the local liquor stores in Edgartown for take-home spirits. Favorites include Rosewater Wine & Spirits and Al’s Package Store.
Drinks in Oak Bluffs
1. The Ritz Cafe
A historic dive bar with a lively atmosphere, The Ritz is a favorite for its live music and community vibe. Located on Circuit Avenue, it’s a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
2. Donovan’s Reef at Nancy’s
This outdoor bar offers breathtaking views of Oak Bluffs Harbor. Try their signature drink, the Dirty Banana—a frozen mix of chocolate, banana, and spirits—or sip on a refreshing margarita while soaking in the views.
3. Offshore Ale Company
For beer lovers, Offshore Ale Company is a must. This brewpub offers a rotating selection of craft beers brewed on-site, including seasonal favorites like Lazy Frog IPA. Pair your drink with one of their famous wood-fired pizzas.
4. The Loft
Looking to dance the night away? The Loft is the Island’s largest nightclub, hosting live music and DJ sets throughout the summer. Its energetic atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for a night out.
Drinks in Vineyard Haven
1. Fish MV
This seafood hotspot is known for its creative cocktails and fresh oysters. Try their watermelon margarita while enjoying views from their covered porch.
2. Black Dog Tavern
A Martha’s Vineyard staple, Black Dog Tavern offers a rustic setting with stunning ocean views. Their full bar features craft wines, beers, and signature cocktails like their Island Mule.
3. Beach Road
For a more upscale evening, Beach Road provides a cozy yet refined experience with Lagoon Pond views. Their menu includes unique cocktails and an impressive selection of craft beers.
Up Island: West Tisbury, Chilmark, and Aquinnah
1. State Road Restaurant
Nestled in West Tisbury, this contemporary tavern features an extensive wine and beer list, paired perfectly with their seasonally inspired dishes.
2. Outermost Inn
Located in picturesque Aquinnah, Outermost Inn offers a serene setting with panoramic views and a well-curated wine and beer menu. Their summer raw bar is an experience in itself.
3. Chilmark Tavern
This BYOB spot is perfect for a quiet evening. Bring your favorite bottle, and they’ll mix it into a custom cocktail with their fresh-made mixers.
Plan Your Perfect Night Out
Martha’s Vineyard offers a little something for everyone, whether you’re after a craft cocktail, local beer, or an elegant wine list. Be sure to explore the Island’s unique towns to discover the best spots for drinks and unforgettable views.
Remember to Drink Responsibly
Always plan ahead with a designated driver or use local cab and ride-share services to ensure a safe journey back to your vacation rental or hotel. Cheers to enjoying the best of Martha’s Vineyard’s drinks and nightlife!
Connect